Hong Kong Academy of Medicine. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
COMMENTARY
Submersion injury in children: a Hong Kong perspective
KL Hon, MD, FAAP; Karen KY Leung, MB, BS, MRCPCH; Jeff CP Wong, MB, BS, MRCPCH
Department of Paediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, The Hong Kong Children’s Hospital, Hong Kong
Corresponding author: Dr KL Hon (ehon@cuhk.edu.hk)
Submersion injury (SI) is one of the three most
common causes of childhood accidental fatalities
worldwide, accounting for approximately 28% of
them.1 According to the World Health Organization’s
World Report on Child Injury Prevention, the rate of
SI fatalities among children is 7.2 deaths per 100 000
population worldwide, and 1.2 per 100 000 population
in high-income countries.1 As per the Childhood
Injuries and Injury Surveillance in Hong Kong, there
were 43 fatalities due to accidental SI among those
aged <19 years from 2001 to 2009, which is 7% of all
deaths of external cause for that age-group.2 In Hong
Kong, SI is uncommon, with a low death rate of 0.34
per 100 000 population.2 According to the Leisure
and Culture Service Department’s 2016 to 2018
special incidents statistics, there has been a decline
in the number of incidents of rescue and SI in public
swimming pools and beaches in Hong Kong.3 In
2018, there were only four deaths due to SI in public
swimming pools and beaches.3 The authors, having
managed two cases of SI in July 2019, would like to
raise awareness of paediatric SI in Hong Kong and
potential public health implications.
Hong Kong experience
Most deaths due to SI in Hong Kong occur in natural
bodies of water; followed by those that occur in
swimming pools.2 4 5 6 Some patients with SI occurring
in mainland China are transported to Hong Kong
for treatment. In our paediatric experience, these
patients appear more likely to incur SI indoors and
are generally younger, have lower Glasgow Coma
Scale score, present with asystole, and require
intubation at the emergency department.7 The risk
of fatal SI is higher among tourists, likely related to
the increased exposure to water when on holiday
and to the unfamiliar environment.1 8 9 Incidents of
SI among tourists are not reported in Hong Kong.
The authors recently experienced two SI cases
involving tourists visiting Hong Kong. The first case
involved a boy with good past health. The patient
was near-drowned in a public swimming pool where
he received on-scene cardiopulmonary resuscitation
(CPR) by the lifeguard on duty. He had a return of
spontaneous circulation after a long duration of resuscitation but subsequently developed multiorgan
dysfunction and died. The second patient was a
teenage girl with good past health. She was near-drowned
in the sea and developed acute respiratory
distress syndrome. Both the caregiver and the
girl were inexperienced swimmers. She required
intensive care and ventilatory support and survived.
Prevention of submersion injuries
Understanding the risk factors can promote effective
prevention of SI. Risk factors for SI included male
sex, age <5 years, ethnic minority status, and
presence of underlying health conditions including
epilepsy, certain cardiac arrhythmia, or autism.1
Environmental factors include exposure to open
water, lack of supervision, lack of available personal
floatation devices or lifeguards, lack of barriers to
prevent children dropping into water, and uneven,
slippery or steep surfaces near or in water.1 The Child
Fatality Review Final Report in 2010 concluded that
two out of three deaths due to SI occurred because
the child swam in places not suitable for swimming
and had overestimated their swimming ability.10
Public education should emphasise vigilant adult
supervision during swimming at all times and
wearing personal floatation devices around water.11
Children should also be encouraged to attend
swimming classes at an early age for basic swimming
skills. Participation in formal swimming lessons is
associated with an 88% reduction in the risk of SI
among children aged 1 to 4 years.12
To preventing SI in natural water, public
education should focus on discouraging swimming
in areas that are unsuitable or unsafe for swimming,
such as lakes and ponds, and understanding and
following public notices, such as beach warning flags.
The public should also be reminded to check the
weather forecast before swimming or participating
in any water activities, and to leave the water
immediately when there is thunder or lightning.13
To prevent SI in swimming pools, pool design
can be reviewed. The Leisure and Culture Services
Department should consider regular audits of
private and public swimming pools to ensure that
they meet safety standards. Fencing and security gates can prevent unauthorised access to swimming
pools. Technological methods may be considered to
supplement present preventive measures against SI.
For example, tele-supervision with multiple video
cameras around swimming pools or beaches, alarms
that can detect individuals who are motionless under
the water for 1 to 2 minutes, or wireless heart rate
monitors for children in public swimming pools.
To prevent indoor SI, buckets or other vessels
should be emptied of water if toddlers are around,
and top-loading washing machines should not be
filled with water when it is not in operation.4 Young
children should not be taken to spas and hot tubs;
when not in use, pools and tubs should be covered.
Improving outcomes of
submersion injuries
The presence of lifeguards may not be sufficient to
prevent SI and related deaths. Prompt effective CPR
by bystanders may improve the chances of survival.
The Hong Kong Life Saving Society is the only
body recognised by the International Life Saving
Federation for assessing and awarding lifeguard
qualifications in Hong Kong. Although the training
of the lifeguards in Hong Kong includes Basic Life
Support and automated external defibrillation, these
qualifications are only reviewed every 3 years. The
health authorities should consider arranging free
refresher courses and simulation training, auditing
lifeguards’ ability to perform CPR, and ensuring
the availability of necessary medical equipment,
especially in private swimming pools.
Potential public health
implications
Financial implications
Both cases involved tourists in Hong Kong and were
non-entitled person under the Hospital Authority
System. Intensive care support is expensive, and the
cost is nearly HK$30 000 per day. Social department
has protocols to waive some of these payments, but it
is not guaranteed to all cases. The judgement call will
be difficult and strict transferral criteria will need to
be in place to prevent the abuse of this system.
Brain death and organ donation
One of the cases had sustained a very significant
insult to the brain, therefore the issues of brain death
and organ donation were discussed. The public has
increased acceptances about the concept of brain
death legally equating cardiopulmonary death over
the past two decades, however it is still not ideal. The
diagnosis of paediatric brain death is seldom made,
making organ donation exceedingly difficult in Hong
Kong.14
Burial issues and aviation transportation of
corpse
The non-survived case is from a different cultural
background. Some religions prohibit postmortem
investigations and demand burial rituals to be
completed within a short period of time following
death. Family members may request repatriation
of the remains. Liaisons with legal department
and airliner are needed to facilitate the process.
According to The International Air Transport
Association Guidelines, the corpse has to be packed
in a hermetically sealed inner containment, inside a
wooden or metal coffin.15 The cost can be significant;
cremated remains might be an alternative if it is
accepted by the family.
Conclusion
Most SIs are preventable. Primary prevention by
health promotion and public health measures to
prevent SI can save lives. Prompt and effective on-scene
CPR can improve survival and outcomes for
patients with SI.
Author contributions
All authors contributed to the concept or design, acquisition
of the data, analysis or interpretation of the data, drafting of
the manuscript, and critical revision of the manuscript for
important intellectual content. All authors had full access to
the data, contributed to the commentary, approved the final
version for publication, and take responsibility for its accuracy
and integrity.
Conflicts of interest
As an editor of the journal, KL Hon was not involved in the peer review process. The other authors have no conflicts of
interest to disclose.
Funding/support
This commentary received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
References
1. Peden M, Oyegbite K, Ozanne-Smith J, et al. World
Report on Child Injury Prevention. Geneva: World Health
Organization; 2008. Crossref
2. Chow CB. Childhood injuries and injury surveillance
in Hong Kong. Available from: https://www.fhs.gov.hk/english/archive/MCHconference2012/presentations/21.pdf. Accessed 2 Sep 2019.
3. Beaches and Swimming Pools, Leisure and Culture Services
Department, Hong Kong SAR Government. Statistics on
special incidents. 2018. Available from: https://www.lcsd.gov.hk/en/beach/atten-general/atten-stat.html. Accessed
4 Sep 2019.
4. Hon KL, Leung TF, Chan SY, Cheung KL, Ng PC. Indoor
versus outdoor childhood submersion injury in a densely
populated city. Acta Paediatr 2008;97:1261-4. Crossref
5. Hon KL, Leung AK. Childhood accidents: injuries and poisoning. Adv Pediatr 2010;57:33-62. Crossref
6. Law AK, Ng MH, Hon KL, Graham CA. Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in the pediatric population in Hong Kong: a 10-year review at a university hospital. Pediatr Emerg Care 2018;34:179-84. Crossref
7. Hon KL, So KW, Wong W, Cheung HM, Cheung KL.
Radiologic, neurologic and cardiopulmonary aspects of
submersion injury. Pediatr Emerg Care 2016;32:623-6. Crossref
8. Mackie IJ. Patterns of drowning in Australia, 1992-1997.
Med J Aust 1999;171:587-90. Crossref
9. Morgan D, Ozanne-Smith J, Triggs T. Descriptive
epidemiology of drowning deaths in a surf beach swimmer
and surfer population. Inj Prev 2008;14:62-5. Crossref
10. Social Welfare Department, Hong Kong SAR Government.
Review Panel of the Pilot Project on Child Fatality Review
Final Report. 2010. Available from: https://www.swd.gov.hk/en/index/site_pubsvc/page_family/sub_fcwdocument/id_cfrp/. Accessed 1 Aug 2019.
11. Food and Health Bureau, Hong Kong SAR Government.
Hong Kong Reference Framework for Preventive Care for Children in Primary Care Settings. 2012. Available
from: https://www.fhb.gov.hk/pho/english/health_professionals/professionals_preventive_children_pdf.
html. Accessed 1 Aug 2019.
12. Brenner RA, Taneja GS, Haynie DL, et al. Association
between swimming lessons and drowning in childhood:
a case-control study. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med
2009;163:203-10. Crossref
13. Leung TH. Non-communicable Disease Watch.
Epidemiology and prevention of unintentional drowning.
2012. Available from: https://www.chp.gov.hk/files/pdf/ncd_watch_jul2012.pdf. Accessed 2 Sep 2019.
14. Hon KL, Poon TC, Wong W, et al. Prolonged non-survival
in PICU: does a do-not-attempt-resuscitation order matter.
BMC Anesthesiol 2013;13:43. Crossref
15. International Air Transport Association. Handling
of Human Remains. IATA Airport Handling Manual.
2011:155. Available from: https://flexmort.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/IATA-Richtlinie-.-s.-155-AHM-333.pdf. Accessed 1 Aug 2019.