© Hong Kong Academy of Medicine. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
DOCTOR FOR SOCIETY
Reaching out to broken angels and resettlers: an interview with Dr Philip Beh
Jaime LY Chung1; Ellen HL Mui2
1 Year 4, Faculty of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong
2 Year 4, Faculty of Medicine, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
One of the hardest lessons in life is to remain
composed when unpredictable external factors
sweep through ferociously, and to persist in striving
for the greater goal.
Dr Philip SL Beh, a renowned forensic
pathologist who worked in the Forensic Pathology
Service, Department of Health for 13 years
before joining the Department of Pathology, The
University of Hong Kong as a Clinical Lecturer in
1995, is no stranger to this philosophy. From co-founding
an organisation called ‘RainLily’ that serves
survivors of sexual violence, to fighting for the rights
of asylum seekers, Dr Beh’s dedication to community
service was never a smooth venture.
Dr Beh’s story began with the decision to start
a career in forensic pathology. Initially started by
chance, Dr Beh grew to appreciate the emerging
development and diversity of forensic pathology.
Apart from examining cadavers in criminal cases,
the responsibility includes clinically assessing
victims of child abuse and sexual violence at the
request of the police. He gradually noticed the
inadequacies of the investigative process carried
out by the police and forensic pathologist: victims
of sexual abuse were frequently transported around
and repeatedly pressed to recount stories to different
strangers, an act that further traumatised the victim.
Police officers and doctors potentially caused more
psychological harm to victims by accusations
and use of inappropriate language. In addition,
no morning-after pill or screening for sexually
transmitted diseases (STDs) were offered, despite
the victims’ universal concern of contracting an
infection or getting pregnant. Dr Beh was stirred to
action when he heard about a girl raped at home by
a construction worker. With inadequate support she
turned to a life of vice.
In an attempt to provide survivors of sexual
abuse with the care they deserve, Dr Beh actively
liaised with doctors, counsellors, and social
workers who shared his passion for women’s and
victims’ rights. In 2000, RainLily was cofounded
by Dr Beh and a group of dedicated women keen
to promote gender equality as a non-governmental
charitable organisation that provided Hong
Kong’s first and only one-stop service for victims
of sexual abuse. One of the major projects under
Association Concerning Sexual Violence Against
Women, RainLily was run by professionals across
disciplines as a pilot programme, supported by
the Lotteries Fund and the Jockey Club. It aims
to provide one-stop assistance including medical
consultation, forensics assessment, counselling, and
police reporting under the same roof, adhering to
international recommendations. Victims of sexual
abuse can receive personalised care and service here:
those wishing for ‘a day in court’ receive legal advice;
those just wanting to mentally recover receive help
from counsellors through artwork, peer self-help
support groups, and a hotline; standard pregnancy
prevention and STD screening is routine.
With signs of reform in the police in the
handling of sexual abuse victims and in the
legislation amendments for rape, Dr Beh was
optimistic about pioneering an overdue change in
the service for victims of sexual violence. This was
not as easy as anticipated. Funding came due and
was discontinued, despite 5 years of established
work with persistently positive feedback from
clients of the service. The Kwong Wah Hospital,
where RainLily had its centre, was also undergoing
renovations and could no longer accommodate the
service. Yet these problems may have been a blessing
in disguise. With the loss of financial support and a
venue, Dr Beh and staff at RainLily were forced to
look for help elsewhere. What was surprising was
that victims voluntarily came forward and shared
their stories on the radio and in the press to fight
for a continuation of the much-needed service. It
was an emotional gesture of courage, community
effort, and trust. Their determination was rewarded
with the establishment of a now permanent sponsor,
Community Chest, and a location at the Prince of
Wales Hospital. Dr Beh is currently involved in the
advisory and negotiation works with the government
and hospitals in favour of a total review of systems
and victims’ cases, supporting the RainLily team in
the provision of up-to-date needs-based protection
of women’s rights and dignity.
Equally unnoticed were the needs of another
marginalised group, asylum seekers. Hong Kong is
a signatory to the international Convention against
Torture and has obligations in assessing the status
of asylum seekers to identify true victims, and to
provide assistance for resettlement. Nonetheless the
huge influx of Vietnamese people from the mid-1970s
not only influenced the political and social context,
but also blurred the line between economic migrants
and true refugees. Public opinion gradually turned
against these asylum seekers. The government’s
engagement in screening them was often impeded
by a language barrier and indifference culminating
in the procrastination about status.
Dr Beh’s first exposure to asylum seekers was
through his job as a forensic pathologist tasked with
writing medical reports for homicides, riots, and rape
cases that had occurred within refugee camps. As he
became more closely involved with these victims,
he developed views very distinct from the general
public who had preconceived ideas and expressed
cultural indifference. Dr Beh recalled their ‘difficult’
living conditions in shacks, relying on aid, forbidden
to work, and waiting endlessly for their asylum
status to be confirmed. Undeterred by cultural
differences and the unfamiliarity of asylum seekers’
countries, Dr Beh gained their trust and learned
about their agonising experiences in war, famine,
torture, child armies, and acid attacks. “When you
really listened to the stories of these people pleading
for refuge, you could never send them home,” Dr Beh
remarked compassionately. This was how Dr Beh
devoted himself to helping asylum seekers through
the physical and psychological trauma as well as the
application process for refugee status.
Since 2000, Dr Beh has been referred cases
by the United Nations High Commissioner for
Refugees and provides medical examinations for
asylum seekers to support their claim for refugee
status. Dr Beh is surprised by the limited number
of referrals for medical assessment, without which
the refugee application process is incomplete. He
speculates that the reason is limited resources and
low priority on the government agenda for managing
asylum seekers, on whose behalf Dr Beh also seeks
to lobby. Even for cases being processed, scars and
evidence would have faded over the years and access
to medical investigations and treatment was finite.
This added to Dr Beh’s frustration.
Dr Beh’s sense of ‘fair-play’ compelled him
to fight for justice for ‘marginalised groups’. An
illustrative example is his defence of a Nepalese
asylum seeker, Limbu Dilbahadur, who was shot
dead by a policeman in 2009. Dr Beh was of the
opinion that the forensic evidence was inconsistent
with the police officer’s account. He regarded the
shooting as unnecessary and unjustified. He fought
to be heard in court and demanded compensation
for the victim’s family. In the end, although a verdict
of lawful killing was issued, Dr Beh considered his
action to have been fair and just.
When asked about his future aspirations and
service plans, he humbly describes his modest wish to
provide better service and care to the marginalised—victims of sexual violence and asylum seekers,
despite the many hurdles and disappointments along
the way. Likewise, he encourages medical students
and young doctors to maintain an interest in current
issues, not just to discuss them but to act. “Nothing
happens too quickly. Only with fervour, patience
and dedication can you make things change for
the greater cause,” Dr Beh added. Dr Beh remains
optimistic about future developments and envisages
more parties joining the fight for humanistic values.
Somebody needs to start somewhere, and the future
lies in the hands of passionate people who really
contemplate what could and should be done.